Job Seekers, Here are 6 Candidate Red Flags Recruiters Look Out For

Job Seekers, Here are 6 Candidate Red Flags Recruiters Look Out For

Everyone knows that getting a rejection email for a job application really sucks. Sadly, about 98% of job seekers are eliminated at the initial resume screening. Only 2% of job seekers make it to an interview.

Unfortunately, recruiters don’t usually give candidates actionable, meaningful feedback on why they were rejected.

To help you catch the “bullseye” of employers, I started sharing the rookie mistakes I see job seekers make time and time again. This series started with an insight into the Biggest Job Application Mistakes You Must Avoid at All Costs, followed by 5 Distinguishing Traits Employers look for in a Prospective New Hire. In this concluding part, we shall review 6 cardinal red flags recruiters look out for in a job candidate. If you are currently looking for a job, well, my friend, it is your lucky day! I am about to show you the cheat sheet hiring managers use for recruiting. 

Are you ready? Here we go!

#1: Inconsistencies and lies

The first red flag for a hiring manager is a discrepancy in a candidate’s resume. This could be in the form of regular employment gaps, lies about past employers, or an embellished job title.

It might be incredibly tempting for job seekers to embellish their resumes in today’s competitive job market. If you’re one of those, think again! Any form of lying on your resume will definitely come back to bite you. When a recruiter determines a discrepancy in your copy (whether online or offline), that’s game over.

The worst-case scenario is when you pulled a “Mike Ross” and eventually get the job. The day the truth materializes, the public humiliation will paint a black stroke over your career prospects, permanently.

Nevertheless, if the discrepancy is in employment gaps, the solution may be in adjusting your resume. Use your summary statement to level with any inconsistency the hiring manager might pick up on. Be sure to keep your copy within 100 words.

#2: Hopping from one job to the other

Profiles that show frequent job-hopping is a big red flag. In fact, talent professionals argue that resumes filled with short-term gigs indicate the candidate lacks commitment, is poor at building relationships, or burns out quickly.

The recruitment process is often time-consuming and expensive. Hence, after a year, losing an employee means wasting precious time and resources on training and development, only to lose the employee before that investment pays off. Plus, many recruiters may assume the employee didn’t have time to learn much at a one-year job, says Jeanne Meister, HR Partner, Future Workplace.

Historically, few available data on how long an average worker should stay in a job in Africa. Nevertheless, career experts recommend that job seekers try to stay at each job for a minimum of two years in an ideal case.

In the words of Amanda Augustine, a career advice expert for TopResume, no matter how badly you want to leave your job or move onto something bigger and better, you don’t want to be branded a serial job-hopper.

That said, if you are faced with the job-hopping or employment gap dilemma, use the functional resume strategy to put a positive spin on your copy. Optimize your template to focus on your skills, what you have achieved, and your abilities rather than time spent in or out of jobs.

#3: A lack of professionalism online

According to Recruiterbox, 43% of employers use social networking sites to research job seekers. Also, 51% of employers who check a candidate’s social media profiles have found content that disqualifies a candidate. In fact, this survey found that 70% of employers use social media to look for red flags on job seekers.

Here are four things your online presence show hiring managers:
1. Stats and results – factual data referencing accomplishments like growth percentages or direct bookings
2. Attention to detail and seriousness – A complete LinkedIn profile shows that the candidate is a detail-oriented and serious job seeker
3. Recommendations from former employers and peers – research shows that the inclusion of testimonials may share more about a candidate’s performance and personality.
4. Community involvement – Participating actively in online groups or volunteering suggests that a candidate has more interest and solid connections with a particular industry or community.

With this understanding, you need to be circumspect with your online interactions. Your digital footprint provides deep insight into who you are, what you care about, and what you bring to the table. Consequently, any serious-minded job seeker will do the legwork of putting a good front on his or her digital platforms.

Use the tips in this article to adjust your digital presence, create a compelling value proposition, and move your career prospects further, faster.

#4: Using ambiguous language

It is common knowledge among recruiters (and supported by research) that you can evaluate candidates’ potential performance based on their speech. The majority of recruiters listen/lookout for the following magic, or the lack thereof when evaluating candidates:

  1. Pronoun: “I” and “me” – studies show that low and average performers use about 400%
    more second-person pronouns like you, your and about 90% more third-person pronouns like he, she, they than high performers.
  2. Tense: workplace experience stories told in the past tense – studies show that low and average performers use the present tense 120% more and the future tense 70% more.
  3. Voice: usage of active voice – studies show that low and average performers often use the passive voice 40%–50% more than high performers.

The use of vague languages, such as “familiar with” or “participated in,” could imply the candidate didn’t actually work on the project, or they assisted in some way, courtesy to a LinkedIn research (This Business Insider article has 36 words and phrases you should never include on your résumé).

#5: Unprofessional profile photo

There’s an old and probably overused saying among marketers: people hear what they see. Inappropriate and unprofessional photos on your social media touchpoints can raise a red flag to recruiters.  They often portray you in an unprofessional light.

So, before you share your next twerk video or Instagram photo with your boobs up in the air, your pants sagging, or your drunken eyes looking at the world like “Klint Da Drunk,” think of the potential career limiting implications of such graphics.

A job seeker is far more likely to make an impression with employers if they have a professional, high-quality photo. The solution is simple: Get dressed up and hire a good photographer, says Ismael Wrixen, CEO, FE International.

#6: Mistakes and typos

In my journey to find the top 10% of entry-level job seekers and match them to jobs with prospects for career progression, personal development, and economic prosperity, I have read thousands of resumes. I have seen the good, the bad, and the hideous ones.

A CareerBuilder survey found that 58% of all resumes have a typo of some form. Resumes with grammatical errors, spelling mistakes, or poor formatting indicate that you lack attention to detail. While some people may want to argue that it is human to make mistakes, many hiring managers have a solid opinion about this matter; almost to the point, and often to the point that one single typo is an automatic veto.

Why? Because how you do anything is how you do everything, the logic goes: if a candidate does not pay attention in getting his or her tenses right, where else will he or she show the same lack of discipline?

Yet, attention to detail is one of the all-time proxies for job qualifications many of us highlight in our resumes. Therefore, if you have the audacity to tell the recruiter that you are “an excellent communicator with great attention to detail,” then you better bring it. Quite frankly, if you don’t, well, it’s your fault for being so sloppy and careless–sorry!

To avoid shooting yourself in the foot before you even start competing for the hiring manager’s attention, please use a grammar checker like Grammarly to proofread your stuff and make necessary adjustments. 

Final thoughts:

There you have it – from pre-screen to post-hire, the knowledge of what hiring managers look for and what they avoid in a candidate is now at your disposal. As the job market becomes increasingly tighter and recruiters continually look for smarter and more sophisticated candidates, the least you can do is to prop yourself up with all the secrets I’ve shared with you in this article. Observe them, commit them to memory, and remember to pay it forward when you have scaled through the process.

Have other tips you noticed? Drop them in the comments.

If you like this article, consider sharing it. Need help finding your perfect job? Reach out to us via To get our bi-weekly email of  career and business insights, Subscribe here

Translate »